How California Homelessness Became A Crisis

For a city as opulent as San Francisco, it’s long been jarring to see the extreme poverty of those experiencing homelessness on its streets. If you walk around downtown, tents, makeshift cardboard beds and human excrement can be seen littering the sidewalks. Impoverished people lie on the ground as a blur of highly paid professionals whiz by.

In 2018, a U.N. official visited San Francisco on a world tour examining housing conditions. She was shocked by what she saw. Her official report concluded that the city’s treatment of unhoused people “constitutes cruel and inhuman treatment and is a violation of multiple human rights, including rights to life, housing, health, water, and sanitation.” The number of homeless San Franciscans has only grown since then to more than 8,000 people, most of whom sleep on the streets, not in shelters.

San Francisco is pretty typical of major American cities these days, especially on the West Coast. Tent cities filled with poverty-stricken people have sprouted up from San Diego to Seattle. As of January 2020, California alone had about 151,000 inhabitants experiencing homelessness.

There are many contributors to the problem. The horrors of childhood trauma and poverty, mental illness and chronic drug abuse surely add to the likelihood that someone lives on the streets. But Nan Roman, president of the National Alliance to End Homelessness, says the primary cause of the crisis is simple: Housing has gotten way too scarce and expensive.

“It’s sort of a game of musical chairs”

A few years ago, a team of economists at Zillow found that once cities cross a threshold where the typical resident must spend more than a third of their income on housing, homelessness begins to spike rapidly. When incomes don’t keep pace with the cost of rent, a cascade effect ripples through the housing market: High-income folks start renting places that middle-income folks used to rent, middle-income people start renting places that low-income folks used to rent, and low-income folks are left scrambling.

“It’s sort of a game of musical chairs,” Roman says. “And people who have a strike against them — because they have mental illness or a substance abuse disorder or a disability — are the least likely to get the chair.”

[Editor’s note: This is an excerpt of Planet Money‘s newsletter. You can sign up here]

Homelessness wasn’t always this bad. “In the 1970s, there was an adequate supply of affordable units for every low-income household that needed one — and we really didn’t have homelessness,” Roman says.

By the 1980s, homelessness emerged as a chronic issue. There were many factors, including the federal government deciding to slash the budget for affordable housing. By then the California state government had significantly cut taxes and gutted social programs, including for state-funded mental institutions, resulting in thousands of people with mental illnesses and other difficulties struggling to make it on their own.

Yet the core reason for the crisis boils down to supply and demand for housing. As regions like the San Francisco Bay Area became magnets for highly paid professionals in the computer-driven economy, they failed to build enough new units to keep up with demand.

A 2016 study by McKinsey Global Institute estimated that California needs 3.5 million new housing units by 2025 to deal with its chronic housing shortage. Yet new housing construction has only slowed since then, despite Gov. Gavin Newsom’s campaign promise to lead an effort to produce those 3.5 million units. Even before the pandemic wrought havoc on the construction business, California was constructing only about 100,000 new homes per year, way below the minimum 180,000 per year that analysts say the state desperately needs.

As Conor Dougherty documents in his illuminating new book, Golden Gates, the politics of building new housing in California is a mess. Homeowners fear new high-rises will blight neighborhoods and damage their home values. Existing renters fear development will cause more gentrification and displace them. Zoning and various regulations make it hard to build new housing.

Many advocates say California needs some kind of new rent control program, but the city of San Francisco passed a rent control law back in 1994, which helped keep existing renters from getting displaced — but only exacerbated the deeper problem of rental scarcity. The 1994 law convinced a large number of San Francisco landlords to take their rentals off the market by doing things like selling their units as condos or bulldozing them and building new ones because the law didn’t apply to new construction. Research finds that the rent control law resulted in a 25% decline in the supply of rentals in the city — during a time when demand was surging.

The result of all this is obscenely high rents and property prices. Combined with stagnating wages for huge swaths of low-income jobs and a lack of political will for spending substantially more on subsidized housing, it’s easy to see why a large population of people has been doubling up, living with their parents, moving to the city’s increasingly expensive outskirts, and being pushed out onto the streets.

What’s different than, say, New York?

Booming cities in other states have arguably done a better job than San Francisco and Los Angeles by at least providing a bandage for the gushing wound. New York City, for example, has a “right to shelter” and a sprawling shelter system that helps people sleep indoors every night. New York City has a rate of homelessness similar to San Francisco and LA, but it has a different character.

As of January 2020, 72% of homeless Californians were unsheltered. Compare that to New York state, where only 5% are unsheltered. The result is a city where homelessness, while still troubling, is also less in-your-face. Warmer weather on the West Coast, which may alter thinking about the cruelty of allowing people to sleep outdoors, could play a role in the difference, but New York has a “right to shelter” because of a 1979 court decision that interpreted the state constitution to give New Yorkers this right.

Instead of building a big system of shelters, California’s cities have taken a more lackadaisical approach that the UC San Diego sociologist Neil Gong calls “tolerant containment” — basically shoeing the unhoused to certain neighborhoods of squalor such as San Francisco’s Tenderloin or Los Angeles’ Skid Row, and then selectively prosecuting them for living on the streets. Gong calls this approach “a Frankenstein’s monster created by mating civil libertarianism with austerity.”

Along came the pandemic

Tristia Bauman, a senior attorney at the National Homelessness Law Center, says California cities have historically been just as vigorous as other cities in forcibly removing encampments and penalizing people for homelessness. In 2018, however, the 9th Circuit Court of Appeals held that the Eighth Amendment’s cruel and unusual punishment clause prohibited cities from penalizing people for sleeping outside when they lack access to indoor shelter or long-term housing. Following that ruling, and in line with CDC guidance advising increased permissiveness during the pandemic, some say West Coast cities, lacking adequate shelters, have increasingly allowed homeless encampments.

Last year, Californians of all political stripes ranked homelessness as the biggest single issue they wanted the state to tackle. With a political groundswell, legal interventions, and the Biden administration providing billions of federal dollars for the cause, California politicians are finally trying to do something big to help people who are unhoused and housing insecure.

Gov. Newsom recently announced a $12 billion plan promising to “provide 65,000 people with housing placements, more than 300,000 people with housing stability and create 46,000 new housing units.” The initiative builds on programs implemented during the pandemic that converted hotels and other buildings into housing for the unhoused. San Francisco Mayor London Breed, following up on a city ballot initiative that authorized taxing big companies and using the funds to help the homeless, wants the city to spend more than a billion dollars on the problem over the next two years.

These programs will hopefully go a long way toward addressing the problem. But as long as California fails to address the root cause — a chronic shortage of affordable housing and an ongoing failure to significantly ramp up new construction — the state seems doomed to grapple with obscene levels of homelessness.

Original Article: https://www.npr.org/sections/money/2021/06/08/1003982733/squalor-behind-the-golden-gate-confronting-californias-homelessness-crisis

March 24, 2021

ROOM $300, Days rd. 1548164002 (Kijiji)

ROOM $300, FEMALES ONLY!! Fully furnished Free onsite laundry Spacious common area Carpet free All utilities and wifi included /1554425209 (Kijiji)

ROOM $450, 549 Alfred st. The house consists of 3 bedrooms and 1 full bathroom on the second level, kitchen, living/dining room and bathroom on the main level and the 4th unit and laundry in the lower level. Bonus huge backyard!! Peaceful and relaxing Parking available. If interested please send a email/text with some info about yourself and we can schedule a viewing $450/month + shared cost of utilities 1 year lease. 1553773695 (Kijiji)

ROOM $460, One bedroom available in Cataraqui Woods home. Available April 1 Mature adult preferred $460/month + utilities (approx. and consistently $100/Month) One female cat in residence. Laundry in basement. 1st and last month required.  1557114218 (Kijiji)

 

ROOM $500, 68 Douglas ave. CHARMING HOUSE UTILITY INCLUDED CALLS ONLY 613 770-4920 EMAILS AND TEXTS WILL NOT BE RESPONDED TO PLEASE… PRIVATE STREET, BUS STOP IN FRONT OF THE HOUSE 1550924412 (Kijiji)

ROOM $550, 1016 Centennial dr. Available may 1st 550$ Inclusive with wifi. /1554546877 (Kijiji)

ROOM $550, Rent as soon as April first , with two laidback and respectful tenants ! The room is not furnished however you should fund everything needed throughout the rest of the apartment such as kitchen bathroom. Pet are allowed Near downtown area Looking to rent out 3 to 6 months possibly longer Rent is 550 plus electricity and internet (split three ways). Don’t hesitate to contact me for picture or possible viewing ! 1556699919 (Kijiji)

ROOM $600, 374 Morningside. Located in a clean modest home in a quite neighbourhood. Master bedroom with queen size bed and computer desk. Use of kitchen, living areas, backyard, laundry. Two full baths, internet all inclusive. 1551081977 (Kijiji)

ROOM $600, County rd 38. Large room and separate sitting room, cable, internet and parking included call Dave 6133899430 1556102163 (Kijiji)

ROOM $650, 4247 Sydenham rd. Bedroom for rent, unfurnished, shared bathroom, livingroom, kitchen, laundry….cable, internet, utilities all included 1555517799 (Kijiji)

ROOM $650, Amherstview. Bedroom for rent Amherstview for 1 person. Available immediately Room has a single bed and is 10 ×10 $650 No smoking and no guest.  1556023362 (Kijiji)

ROOM $650, The room has a queen bed, walk in closet, hardwood floors, two windows so the room is very bright! The home is large, well maintained and very clean. Rent is $650.00 per month and includes wifi and utilities. We also have a large stone patio in the back yard and a hot tub which can be used if you are willing to chip in with chemical costs… approx $10 per month. The home is close to downtown and on two express bus routes. For more information please contact Dan by return email or by text at 613-328-8854 1555869669 (Kijiji)

ROOM $750, Room in motel monthly. Parking, phone, TV. Own entry, washroom. Available now. Call Doug 613-542-7651 1494701212 (Kijiji)

BACHELOR $995, 544 college. Avail..April large bachelor apart $895.00 Incl..heat hot @ cold water near bus stop laundry new hardwood ceramic floors secure building elevator parking South side for viewing @ appointment Call 343-333-3811  1556504822 (Kijiji)

BACHELOR $975, 288 Union st. lower level of this multi-unit property. It is partially furnished with a table and chairs. Appliances included are a fridge, microwave and hotplate. There is also on-site laundry and parking available but not included. Located in a great location, only a few blocks to Queen’s University and a short walk to Kingston General Hospital. utilities included. 1533624673 (Kijiji)

BACHELOR $995, 22 Colbourne. Laundry on site. Parking $115 per month. Utilities: Not included Please e-mail us at info@bpedevelopment.com or call us at 613-507-9116 for further information or to set up a showing! Visit our website at www.bpe-rentals.com to see more of our beautiful units. 1549596685 (Kijiji)

BACHELOR $995, 31 Bayswater. We are looking for someone to take over our lease. All utilities included, for Osgoode properties. Call if interested 613-542-9590. 1555054023 (Kijiji)

BACHELOR $995, 204 Montreal. Beside flower shop. Bright large windows, very clean Newer furniture Heat, water, light, inclusive. PHONE CALLS ONLY PLEASE Marilyn 613453 8570 1553765891 (Kijiji)

BACHELOR $995, Wellington st. Semi-basement with Bed-Sitting Room; Office/Dining Area; Kitchen; Oak Floors; Built-in Dresser & Shelves; FREE: Laundry, Heat, Electricity and Water. Available May 1st. NO SMOKING & NO PETS  1556768453 (Kijiji)

BACHELOR $995, Bayswater. Water heat hydro incl. Outdoor Parking – $35. 1556590760 (Kijiji)

BACHELOR $1050, 300 Regent. Practical bachelor apartment in great central location near the Kingston Centre. Features: – Laminate flooring – Big bright windows – Laundry in building If you have any questions regarding this unit please call our office 613-542-7343 or email apartments@springergroup.com  (Kijiji) 1539129301

BACHELOR $1100, 65 Nelson. There is an air conditioner and heat and water are included. Washing machine and dryer available for tenants in the basement and parking space is available at an extra cost. Can be rented furnished or not. Lease can be from May to August 2021 or May2021 to April 2022. $1100 unfurnished, $1150 furnished, $50 parking if needed .Please text or email me.  1552418478 (Kijiji)

1 BEDROOM $825, 547 Brock st. Landlord requires first and last months rent, and post-dated cheque for each month of the duration of the lease. Landlord provides stove, fridge, and one free parking space. Electricity to be paid by tenants. Heat and water to be paid by landlord. Tenant agrees not to sublet without leave. No smoking. No pets. In house laundry. Hardwood floor. One year lease required. 1553163784 (Kijiji)

1 BEDROOM $840, Ordnance st. Downtown near Artillery Park. Close to shopping, restaurants. One bedroom unit on third floor. Rent includes heat and water. Tenant pays electricity. Available April. References. 1557064686 (Kijiji)

1 BEDROOM $845, 116 Toronto st. One bedroom apartment for rent located at the intersection of Brock and Toronto Streets. Features private entrance with deck, 3-piece bathroom, bright rooms and parking available.. This unit is renting for $845/month plus electricity and shared water/sewer. 1553855257 (Kijiji)

1 BEDROOM $875, 310 Yonge st. One Bedroom very bright and cheery lower unit, smoke and pet free. Fabulous South Side location approximately one km from Providence Care and bus stop located conveniently right out front. Freshly painted and recently upgraded with all new insulated exterior walls and thermal pane windows to keep you warm in the winter and cool in the summer. No smoking and no pets please. Includes all window coverings, fridge, stove, microwave, and one parking spot. Available April 1st, possibly sooner. First/last/Ref/Credit check. Please call Sandra at 613-546-2347 for more info and to arrange veiwing. 1556706119 (Kijiji)

1 BEDROOM $975, 15 Regent st. Cozy Bright One-Bedroom apartment located in great neighborhood with bus stop, park near by, on site laundry, 1 parking spot. Close to Queen’s, St. Lawrence and Hospitals. 1554901616

1 BEDROOM $985, This apartment is located at the corner of princess and Division Street. There is a set of stairs to enter the apartment. Through the front door is the kitchen which leads to the dining/living room area. Off of the living room is the separate bedroom and four piece bathroom. This apartment is available for $985 per month plus electricity. Landlord pays for heat and water. Available now or April 1, first and last month’s rent required. Please contact for a viewing. 1556463187  (Kijiji)

1 BEDROOM $1000, 7798 Victoria. Great one bedroom apartment for rent in great neighbourhood close to schools and park next door within walking distance of the Kingston Center in downtown Kingston apartment has new floors new paint on walls new windows there is a side yard to enjoy call or text Vince for showings at 343-333-8468 do not email I don’t get them 1554799093 (Kijiji)

1 BEDROOM $1000, 382 Victoria. Parking inc. All inclusive. Shared laundry.  emailrentals@limestonepm.ca . (613) 530-3340  1552894870 (Kijiji)

1 BEDROOM $1049, 16 Leroy Grant Drive, Call 613-541-0678 to arrange a viewing! One-bedroom available for immediately. Monthly rent from $1,049.00-1,215.00 plus electricity, Parking is $45-65 monthly(outdoor) For more information on this building including amenities, photos and floor plans please visit: https://www.homestead.ca/apartments/16-leroy-grant-drive-kingston1505826930 (Kijiji)

1 BEDROOM $1050, Johnson st.  Bright, basement apartment in quiet building, on bus route, 1 parking space, near college and university and hospitals. 1556230186 (Kijiji)

1 BEDROOM $1053, Brock st. Clean, located near park, walking distance to Queens. Full kitchen with new dishwasher, private entrance, full bath with storage, built in bookshelf, bedroom and sitting area in one room large enough for queen bed, couch night table and dresser. 1556382296 (Kijiji)

1 BEDROOM $1063, 310 Westdale Ave. Pet friendly. Resident Laundry Room . You can log onto: www.braeburyproperties.com to fill out a pre approval application. Call or email more information (613) 546-3400. tyler@braeburyproperties.com. 1553863954 (Kijiji)

1 BEDROOM $1075, 1015 Pembridge cr. Outdoor Parking – $40. Visitor Parking. Balconies. Pet Friendly. Water – Included. Laundry. 1555106597 (Kijiji)

1 BEDROOM $1075, Fifth Ave. Rent is $1075.00.00, all inclusive Available on a 12 month lease Available May 1st, 2021. Please contact Heron Management for more information or to book a showing at (613)-766-1659 or go to http://www.heronmanagement.com 1556030000 (Kijiji)

1 BEDROOM $1099, 175 Park st.  Call 613-546-1462 to arrange a viewing! Parking 52-72. Avail Jan  Plus electricity. 1539241675 (Kijiji)

1 BEDROOM $1095, 561 Princess. Parking Not Included. Available Now. Tenant pays hydro (avg. $35/month). Quiet and secure building. Laundromat close by. For more information, please e-mailrentals@limestonepm.ca. Phone: 613 530-3340 1547226802 (Kijiji)

1 BEDROOM $1100, 214 Montreal st. Recently renovated one bedroom unit for rent in downtown Kingston. Updated with new kitchen, bathroom fixtures, flooring and fresh paint, this unit includes a bright livingroom and bedroom, 3-piece bathroom, eat-in kitchen with fridge and stove. Parking at property for an additional cost and based on availability. 1544627388 (Kijiji)

1 BEDROOM $1100, 234 Johnson st.  Large one bedroom located on the 3rd floor of an old house. This includes the entire floor, inside entrance. 2 mins from Hotel Dieu and 5 mins from Queens. 1100 plus hydro. Includes internet Furnished. Hot water heating References required contact tbturn@gmail.com video tour is available txt at 613-539-9066 1555301275  (Kijiji)

1 BEDROOM $1100, 40 Connaught. Features living room with hardwood floors that opens up to a great working kitchen with lots of counter and cupboard space, 4-piece bathroom with lots of storage, two bright bedrooms and two entrance/exit doors that includes a private entrance with mudroom that leads out to a deck and shared back yard area. One parking spot available. Renting for $1100/month plus electricity and water/sewer which averages $120/month.  /1555169099 (Kijiji)

1 BEDROOM $1100, 535 Rideau st. Clean 1 bedroom apartment at Montreal St and Rideau St. This apartment has been fully renovated. Laundry facility, 1 parking, fridge and stove are included at $1100 per month plus Hydro. Apartment address is 535 Rideau St. Kingston. Close to downtown Kingston and close to a bus stop, walk trail. For inquiry, please call 613-539-9034. 1556357864 (Kijiji)

2 BEDROOM $1100, 63 Cowdy. There are two bedroom units . the basement unit is ready for rent and the rent is $1100 per month plus hydro(and heating). second floor unit needs repairing and is available on March 1 for $1200 per month plus hydro(and heating). I am also looking for dependable young couple or students who are able to and willing to help me to do minor repairs and maintenances. ph:613-480-6627 1554380703 (Kijiji)

2 BEDROOM $1165, 80 & 84 William st. Available April 1st, two bedroom apartment with a balcony Also available parking and on-site laundry facilities. Features include security building and extensive use of hardwood and ceramic flooring throughout the unit. From $1165.00 including water. /1553046907 (Kijiji)

2 BEDROOM $1165, 90 Curtis cres. HOMESTEAD LAND HOLDINGS. Call 613-531-5298 to arrange a viewing!, plus electricity, Parking is $50-70 monthly(outdoor) For more information on this building including amenities, photos and floor plans please visit: https://www.homestead.ca/apartments/90-curtis-crescent-kingston1505826777 (Kijiji)

2 BEDROOM $1175, 332 Montreal. Walking distance to downtown Kingston. The unit is an upstairs small 2 bedroom in a semi detached duplex. It comes with washer/dryer in unit, hardwood floors, small balcony, 3 piece bathroom, and parking spot in front of house. Electricity is extra. Available June 1st. Please text Taylor @ 416-737-2941. 1555685888 (Kijiji)

2 BEDROOM $1200, 122 Princess. rentals@limestonepm.ca Tenant pays hydro. Available May 1, 2021. Coin operated laundry in building. Phone: 613 530-3340 1554099640 (Kijiji)

2 BEDROOM $1295, 544 College St. Available April.  Incl heat, water, parking. Call 343-333-3811 1555401084 (Kijiji)

 

BEDROOM $1250, 1010 Pembridge. Available May 1, 2021. Tenant pays hydro.  Coin operated laundry. For more info e-mail rentals@limestonepm.ca (KIJIJI) Limestone Property Management- Phone: 613 530-3340

2 BEDROOM $1275, Priced right! Perfect location, Quiet building, Available Now! Easy to maintain lament flooring though out and a new kitchen as well as lots of storage area. Parking and laundry facilities are on site. Heat and Water included, Electric is extra. No dogs and No smoking. First and last month’s rent along with a one year lease is required. If interested in a viewing; an online application must submitted. 1549987088  (Kijiji)

2 BEDROOM $1200, 85 Toronto St. Parking Available at cost. Laundry in building. Call or email The Braebury Residential Team for more information. (613) 546-3400 tina@braeburyhomes.com 1554707670 (Kijiji)

2 BEDROOM $1200, 17 Eldon hallContact Tribond Property Management for more information! 613-985-1987 or info@tribondpm.com. large in-suite storage room and a balcony with space for seating. This building includes laundry on every floor, an elevator, modern lobby and a superintendent on-site & 1 parking space included. Water is included and hydro is extra. Pet free building. 1533743121 (Kijiji)

2 BEDROOM $1275, 196 Concession. This apartment is $1,275.00, plus electric (heat & water included) First and last month’s rent required on a 12 month lease Available May 1st, 20211556917004  (Kijiji)

2 BEDROOM $1295, 251 Macdonnell. Available May 1, 2021. Tenant pays hydro. Parking for one vehicle included. Coin operated laundry on site. E-mail rentals@limestonepm.ca if interested. Phone: 613 530-3340 1554099782 (Kijiji)

 

2 BEDROOM $1300, 550 Union st. Mar 1. Amenities included: refrigerator and stove, shared coin laundry on-site. Electricity is extra. Heat, water and sewer included in rent. 1549446345 (Kijiji)

 

2 BEDROOM $1325, 239 Regent St. Parking not incl. Available Oct 1. Tenant pays hydro. Lower level unit. Laundry in building. 1514638430 (Kijiji)

2 BEDROOM $1350, 316 Westdale. Pet friendly. Laundry. (613) 453-2783 staceybraeburyproperties@gmail.com

 

2 BEDROOM $1350, 130 The Parkway. Call 613-541-3696 to arrange a viewing! Available March. Plus electricity. 1544545571 (Kijiji)

 

2 BEDROOM $1350, 211 Queen Mary. Parking Included. Available Now. Walk-out balcony. For more information, please email rentals@limestonepm.ca. 613 530-3340 1555269998 (Kijiji)

 

2 BEDROOM $1350, 107 Compton st. Available September 25. Water inc. Balcony. Storage. Outdoor parking. Laundry. 1505833938 (Kijiji) 

3 BEDROOM $1575, 3 Bedroom apartment close to St Lawrence, Close to downtown. 10 min to queens. Bright spacious bedrooms. hardwood floors throughout. In floor heating . 5 appliances. washer/dryer in the unit. fridge stove dishwasher, microwave Close to shops, buses, waterfront. Very quiet building with lots of parking. Front unit upstairs 1575monthly plus utilities. Available now. Call 613 328 9464  apply on line www.barryprop.ca 1553560322 (Kijiji)

3 BEDROOM $1595, 35 Eldon Hall, 3bd townhouse Eldon Hall Place, close to amenities, utilities included except W/S, non-smoking. 1557050587  (Kijiji)

3 BEDROOM $1600, Located at the corner of Princess and Division St, this apartment is located on the second floor and has its own entrance. Past this are three separate bedrooms and the four piece bathroom. Available now or April 1 the rent for this apartment is $1600 plus electricity. Some furnishings available if required. Landlord pays for water. 1553348001 (Kijiji)

This website uses cookies to ensure you get the best experience on our website.

Skip to content